Wednesday, May 23, 2012

An Assembly Line!

Henry Ford in 1909 is said to have said "Any customer can have a car painted any colour that he wants so long as it is black", about the Model T. Ford ushered in the assembly line concept taht revolutionized manufacturing and to large extent process efficiency. He also said "The average man won't really do a day's work unless he is caught and cannot get out of it". Henry Ford was a hard driving man who made his own rules and lived by them in a fast changing world. Fast forward to present day India and what is said to be one of the toughest examinations in the world to crack, the IITJEE. The examination always was a test of intelligence, skill, hard work and perseverance, where teens slog long hours to achieve a place in some of India's top technical colleges. Today in India, admission to these institutions resembles Ford's assembly line. Kids are taken from home and dumped in hostels, grilled for hours on end, away from their parents and eventually many do make it to the IIT's. But at what cost? Former Infosys Head Honcho, N.R.Narayanamurthy said a few months ago that the quality of students at the IIT's were dipping and that there were a singular lack of innovation. I'm sure the assembly line concept has something to do with this. To circumvent, this system India's current minister of education has said that, entry to the IIT's will henceforth carry a component from the 12th Grade passing out marks. This would preclude the assembly liners in coaching kids only for the IIT's at the exclusion of all else. However with the ingenuity of the Indian mind, I'm sure coaching centres would find a way around this initiative, by maybe roping in kids when they are ten or so and putting them on the assembly line. The point I'm trying to make is that, we need to be efficient, however should all our cars be black and should we collar kids and grind them to get them to join an institution of national importance? Can you compare a custom made Ferrari to a Ford Sedan? Assembly lines are good to a point, but when efficiency turns into a national obsession it can be debilitating.It kills creativity and innovation. When I see an Alfa Romeo go by, I tip my hat, is what Ford had to finally say of the superbly designed and crafted Alfa Romeo, which did not come off the assembly line.

9 comments:

Vishnu Raghavan said...

stifling creativity is a phenomenon that is quite common sir. evan ivan illych spoke of a phenomenon called deschooling so that this trend of loss of creativity could be arrested

Vishnu Raghavan said...

stifling creativity is a phenomenon that is quite common sir. evan ivan illych spoke of a phenomenon called deschooling so that this trend of loss of creativity could be arreste

Vishnu Raghavan said...

stifling creativity is a phenomenon that is quite common sir. evan ivan illych spoke of a phenomenon called deschooling so that this trend of loss of creativity could be arrested

Vishnu Raghavan said...

the more this trend increases sir the greater is a chance of increased uniformity of thought. r d laing, david cooper have also spoken of how this will lead to the formation of a horde of endlessly obedient citizens. laing even remarked
Children do not give up their innate imagination, curiosity, dreaminess easily. You have to love them to get them to do that. so its a telling comment on what paternalistic despotism may do if indulged in excess

Capt A.Nagaraj Subbarao said...

nice analysis Vishnu.......we seem to have this wonderful ability to reduce the best to mediocrity by circumventing systems mostly out of ignorance and a die hard herd mentality!

Vishnu Raghavan said...

http://www.thehindu.com/opinion/editorial/article3654444.ece
dear sir this makes disturbing and interesting reading would desire to have your opinion page

Vishnu Raghavan said...

of course the key reason the system is fraught with problems is that too much of a class divide exists and its not just in india

Vishnu Raghavan said...

http://www.thehindu.com/opinion/editorial/article3654445.ece
dear sir
this is more evidence of reflexive obedience the hallmark of the japanese people. the movie the last samurai seems to celebrate this trait, and if im not mistaken the kamikaze pilots to die for the emperor

Vishnu Raghavan said...

did so gladly